I have been debating how to share this article, which was published back in 2014. Since this blog is fairly permanent, and also of very limited distribution, I decided to put it here. I can't offend too many people, because no one reads this thing. AND . . when I want to find it, I know where to look.
This is the article reference:
https://waitbutwhy.com/2014/10/religion-for-the-nonreligious.html
Religion for the Non-Religious
That is the title all right, but don't be put off by it. This is a wonderful little summary of the latest evolutionary neuroscience research, coupled with a step by step explanation of how to gain real wisdom. I taught Steven Covey's 7 Habits for a decade or more and this author has condensed ihuis approach to a simple plan - with cool illustrations!
Covey developed his approach primarily by reading self help books. And back when he wrote, our understanding of how the human brain worked was still pretty minimal. We are now shedding a bit of light on our internal cognitive processes, and it seems Covey was really on to something. He did it primarily by observation and analysis, but we can step beyond that now. This author does it with pictures. Very cool.
Background
We are not very rational beings. If you have read anything I have posted here, our brains are awash with all kinds of instinctual things that drive our elephant hither and yon. Our slow brain takes a lot of energy, and it is really hard to stop and think things through - even when we want to do that. See the books I have cited: Thinking Fast and Slow, Righteous Minds, etc. Our evolving brain has arrived at intelligence, but we have not left behind any of the primary, instinctual things that got us to this point. And they get in the way of the thinking part pretty effectively.
With a little bit of work, some mindfulness and understanding of just what is going on in our heads and hearts, we can overcome that instinctual beast a bit, and get to some level of self knowledge - on occasion.
The good thing is that he greatly simplifies the problem, so that brings it home much more clearly to our "cluttered" brain. And the illustrations are cool.
Outline
I was going to give you some idea of what he put in here, But . . . just have it. It is good fun, nicely illustrated for "those of us who do not read". See Scheider's rules for life.
One Critique - No Tribal
I think he missed one big "emotion" or "fog" that seems to drive us more than any others - our need to belong to a TRIBE. We are social beings, and we go with the tribe without even thinking about it. It is our identity and protection. Just recognizing that is a major step up the ladder. When we realize that our actual tribe is every living thing, then we can get with the program.
When are those Vikings playing again?
Comments by Carl Scheider on life and stuff. Updates are irregular. Comments at the bottom. Stay Safe.
Subscribe for updates
Sunday, September 2, 2018
Sunday, May 20, 2018
Steven Pinker, Enlightenment Now - Book Report / Review
Bill Gates said this is his current best book ever. I agree with him.
Enlightenment Now by Steven Pinker.
Dr. Pinker is a Harvard faculty member, Professor of Cognitive Psychology - which means he studies the way the brain operates, not just what we do with it. The best thing about the book is that he is aware of virtually every recent study of human beings and social issues, and he always brings a very refreshing take to each problem. And he is, at the same time, incredibly literate, and he makes literature, movie and song references that are stellar. And, while avowedly progressive, he is middle of the road on liberal / conservative. He strikes a nice, informed balance.
He is tremendously optimistic about the potential for continuing our progress forward. He analyzes each of the major problems we are facing, he looks at the historical trends, at the actual data, and at the latest research - and gets your brain around his perspective.
I highly recommend this - if you are at all interested in the topics that I am engaged in, I predict you will also love this book. I would like to persuade everyone to read the book- but most of those who really should get some of this enlightenment would never even pick the thing up. There is no original research in here, but he fills you up with all manner of recent research on cognitive, social and political issues. The book is fact filled - and lots of new information and perspectives that I found fascinating. And you should too!
Check out the things which Bill Gates found interesting at his website, and then read mine as well. You will see that Bill and I have a very different focus on life!
Mine:
-------------------
Enlightenment Now by Steven Pinker.
Dr. Pinker is a Harvard faculty member, Professor of Cognitive Psychology - which means he studies the way the brain operates, not just what we do with it. The best thing about the book is that he is aware of virtually every recent study of human beings and social issues, and he always brings a very refreshing take to each problem. And he is, at the same time, incredibly literate, and he makes literature, movie and song references that are stellar. And, while avowedly progressive, he is middle of the road on liberal / conservative. He strikes a nice, informed balance.
He is tremendously optimistic about the potential for continuing our progress forward. He analyzes each of the major problems we are facing, he looks at the historical trends, at the actual data, and at the latest research - and gets your brain around his perspective.
I highly recommend this - if you are at all interested in the topics that I am engaged in, I predict you will also love this book. I would like to persuade everyone to read the book- but most of those who really should get some of this enlightenment would never even pick the thing up. There is no original research in here, but he fills you up with all manner of recent research on cognitive, social and political issues. The book is fact filled - and lots of new information and perspectives that I found fascinating. And you should too!
Check out the things which Bill Gates found interesting at his website, and then read mine as well. You will see that Bill and I have a very different focus on life!
Mine:
-------------------
Page 3 Meaning and Purpose
The question posed to the author was: “Given all of this, why should I live?”
Given that traditional religious beliefs about an immortal soul are undermined by our best science, why live? His answer:
In the very act of asking that question, you are seeking reasons for your convictions, and so you are committed to reason as the means to discover and justify what is important to you. And there are so many reasons to live!
As a sentient being, you have the potential to flourish. You can refine your faculty of reason itself by learning and debating. You can see explanations of the natural world through science, and insight into the human condition through the arts and humanities. You can make the most of your capacity for pleasure and satisfaction, which allowed your ancestors to thrive and thereby allowed you to exist. You can appreciate the beauty and richness of the natural and cultural world. As the heir to billions of years of life perpetuating itself, you can perpetuate life in turn. You have been endowed with a sense of sympathy –the ability to like, love, respect, help, and show kindness – and you can enjoy the gift of mutual benevolence with friends, family, and colleagues.
And because reason tells you that none of this is particular to you, you have the responsibility to provide to others would you expect for yourself. You can foster the welfare of others sentient beings by enhancing life, health, knowledge, freedom, abundance, safety, beauty, and peace. History shows that when we sympathize with others and apply our ingenuity to improving the human condition, we can make progress in doing so, and you can help to continue that progress.
-----------------------------
Page 11 Sympathy will prevail - I would prefer "empathy".
Given that we are equipped with the capacity to sympathize with others, nothing can prevent the circle of sympathy from expanding from the family and tribe to embrace all of humankind, particularly as reason goads us into realizing that there can be nothing uniquely deserving about ourselves or any of the groups to which we belong. We are forced into cosmopolitanism: accepting our citizenship in the world.
---------------
Page 113 Inequality
Now that we have run through the history of inequality and seen the forces that push it around, we can evaluate the claim that the growing inequality of the past three decades means that the world is getting worse - that only the rich have prospered, while everyone else is stagnating or suffering. The rich certainly have prospered more than anyone else, perhaps more than they should have, but the claim about everyone else is not accurate, for a number of reasons.
Most obviously, it's false for the world as a whole: the majority of the human race has become much better off. The two-humped camel has become a one hump Dromedary; the elephant has a body the size of, well, and elephant; extreme poverty has plummeted and may disappear; and both International and global inequality coefficients are in decline. Now, it's true that the world's poor have gotten richer in part at the expense of the American lower-middle-class, and if I were an American politician I would not publicly say that the trade-off was worth it. But as citizens of the world considering humanity as a whole, we have to say that the trade-off is worth it.
----------------------------
P. 118 Some of Our Major Problems
Education, a major driver of economic mobility, is not keeping up with the demands of modern economies: tertiary education has soared in cost ( defying the inexpensification of almost every other good ), and in poor American neighborhoods, primary and secondary education are unconscionably substandard. Many parts of the American tax system are aggressive, and money buys too much political influence.
------------------------
P. 145 carbon pricing
You really want to read this - I thought I had understood carbon pricing - but this makes it very clear how it should work.
----------------------------
P. 205 Democracy - in a pragmatic nutshell
If neither voters nor elected leaders can be counted on to uphold the ideals of democracy, why should this form of government work so not-badly - the worst form of government except all the others that have been tried, as Churchill famously put it? In his 1945 book The Open Society and its Enemies, the philosopher Karl Popper argued that democracy should be understood not as the answer to the question “Who should rule? “ (namely, “The People”), but as a solution to the problem of how to dismiss bad leadership without bloodshed. The political scientist John Mueller brought this idea from a binary Judgement Day to continuous day-to-day feedback. Democracy, he suggests, is essentially based on giving people the freedom to complain: “It comes about when the people affected the agree not to use violence to replace the leadership, and the leadership leaves them free to try to dislodge it by any other means. “ He explains how this can work:
If citizens have the right to complain, to petition, to organize, to protest, to demonstrate, to strike, to threaten to emigrate or secede, to shout, to publish, to export their funds, to express a lack of confidence, and to wheedle in back corridors, government will tend to respond to the sounds of the shouters and the importunings of the wheedlers: that is, it will necessarily become responsive - pay attention - whether there are elections or not.
-------------
P 297 On the dangers of AI.
There is no law of complex systems that says that intelligent agents must turn into ruthless conquistadors. Indeed, we know of one highly advanced form of intelligence that evolved without this defect. They're called women.
--------------
Page 405 - The FACTS for non violent resistance. One last one - one of the best insights in the book. If only we could persuade the Palestinians of this simple FACT.
Do multi-ethnic regions harbor ancient hatreds that can only be tamed by partitioning them into ethnic enclaves and cleansing the minorities from each one? Whenever ethnic neighbors go for each other's throats we read about it, but what about the neighborhoods that never make the news because they live in boring piece? What proportion of pairs of ethic neighbors coexist without violence? The answer is, most of them: 95% of the neighbors in the former Soviet Union, 99% of those in Africa.
Do campaigns of nonviolent resistance work? Many people believe that Gandhi and Martin Luther King just got lucky: their movements tugged at the heartstrings of enlightened democracies at opportune moments, but everywhere else, oppressed people need violence to get out from under a dictator's boot. The political scientist Erica Chenoweth and Maria Stephan assembled a dataset of political resistance movements across the world between 1900 and 2006 and discover that three-quarters of the nonviolent resistance movement compared to with only a third of the violent ones. Gandhi and King were right, but without data, you would never know it.
Though the urge to join a violent Insurgent or terrorist group may owe more to male bonding than to just-war theory, most of the combatants probably believe that if they want to bring about a better world, they have no choice but to kill people. What would happen if everyone knew that violent strategies were not just immoral but ineffectual? It's not that I think we should airdrop crates of Chenoweth and Stevens book into conflict zones. But leaders are radical groups are often highly educated (they just steal their frenzy from academic scribblers of a few years back), and even the cannon fodder often attend some college and absorb about the conventional wisdom about the need for violence. What would happen over the long run if a standard college curriculum devoted less attention to the writings of Karl Marx and Frantz Fanon and more to quantitative analysis of political violence?
-----
That's enough. You have probably not read this far anyway. Buy the book, get from your library. Whatever works. And let me know what you think.
As a sentient being, you have the potential to flourish. You can refine your faculty of reason itself by learning and debating. You can see explanations of the natural world through science, and insight into the human condition through the arts and humanities. You can make the most of your capacity for pleasure and satisfaction, which allowed your ancestors to thrive and thereby allowed you to exist. You can appreciate the beauty and richness of the natural and cultural world. As the heir to billions of years of life perpetuating itself, you can perpetuate life in turn. You have been endowed with a sense of sympathy –the ability to like, love, respect, help, and show kindness – and you can enjoy the gift of mutual benevolence with friends, family, and colleagues.
And because reason tells you that none of this is particular to you, you have the responsibility to provide to others would you expect for yourself. You can foster the welfare of others sentient beings by enhancing life, health, knowledge, freedom, abundance, safety, beauty, and peace. History shows that when we sympathize with others and apply our ingenuity to improving the human condition, we can make progress in doing so, and you can help to continue that progress.
-----------------------------
Page 11 Sympathy will prevail - I would prefer "empathy".
Given that we are equipped with the capacity to sympathize with others, nothing can prevent the circle of sympathy from expanding from the family and tribe to embrace all of humankind, particularly as reason goads us into realizing that there can be nothing uniquely deserving about ourselves or any of the groups to which we belong. We are forced into cosmopolitanism: accepting our citizenship in the world.
---------------
Page 113 Inequality
Now that we have run through the history of inequality and seen the forces that push it around, we can evaluate the claim that the growing inequality of the past three decades means that the world is getting worse - that only the rich have prospered, while everyone else is stagnating or suffering. The rich certainly have prospered more than anyone else, perhaps more than they should have, but the claim about everyone else is not accurate, for a number of reasons.
Most obviously, it's false for the world as a whole: the majority of the human race has become much better off. The two-humped camel has become a one hump Dromedary; the elephant has a body the size of, well, and elephant; extreme poverty has plummeted and may disappear; and both International and global inequality coefficients are in decline. Now, it's true that the world's poor have gotten richer in part at the expense of the American lower-middle-class, and if I were an American politician I would not publicly say that the trade-off was worth it. But as citizens of the world considering humanity as a whole, we have to say that the trade-off is worth it.
----------------------------
P. 118 Some of Our Major Problems
Education, a major driver of economic mobility, is not keeping up with the demands of modern economies: tertiary education has soared in cost ( defying the inexpensification of almost every other good ), and in poor American neighborhoods, primary and secondary education are unconscionably substandard. Many parts of the American tax system are aggressive, and money buys too much political influence.
------------------------
P. 145 carbon pricing
You really want to read this - I thought I had understood carbon pricing - but this makes it very clear how it should work.
----------------------------
P. 205 Democracy - in a pragmatic nutshell
If neither voters nor elected leaders can be counted on to uphold the ideals of democracy, why should this form of government work so not-badly - the worst form of government except all the others that have been tried, as Churchill famously put it? In his 1945 book The Open Society and its Enemies, the philosopher Karl Popper argued that democracy should be understood not as the answer to the question “Who should rule? “ (namely, “The People”), but as a solution to the problem of how to dismiss bad leadership without bloodshed. The political scientist John Mueller brought this idea from a binary Judgement Day to continuous day-to-day feedback. Democracy, he suggests, is essentially based on giving people the freedom to complain: “It comes about when the people affected the agree not to use violence to replace the leadership, and the leadership leaves them free to try to dislodge it by any other means. “ He explains how this can work:
If citizens have the right to complain, to petition, to organize, to protest, to demonstrate, to strike, to threaten to emigrate or secede, to shout, to publish, to export their funds, to express a lack of confidence, and to wheedle in back corridors, government will tend to respond to the sounds of the shouters and the importunings of the wheedlers: that is, it will necessarily become responsive - pay attention - whether there are elections or not.
-------------
P 297 On the dangers of AI.
There is no law of complex systems that says that intelligent agents must turn into ruthless conquistadors. Indeed, we know of one highly advanced form of intelligence that evolved without this defect. They're called women.
--------------
Page 405 - The FACTS for non violent resistance. One last one - one of the best insights in the book. If only we could persuade the Palestinians of this simple FACT.
Do multi-ethnic regions harbor ancient hatreds that can only be tamed by partitioning them into ethnic enclaves and cleansing the minorities from each one? Whenever ethnic neighbors go for each other's throats we read about it, but what about the neighborhoods that never make the news because they live in boring piece? What proportion of pairs of ethic neighbors coexist without violence? The answer is, most of them: 95% of the neighbors in the former Soviet Union, 99% of those in Africa.
Do campaigns of nonviolent resistance work? Many people believe that Gandhi and Martin Luther King just got lucky: their movements tugged at the heartstrings of enlightened democracies at opportune moments, but everywhere else, oppressed people need violence to get out from under a dictator's boot. The political scientist Erica Chenoweth and Maria Stephan assembled a dataset of political resistance movements across the world between 1900 and 2006 and discover that three-quarters of the nonviolent resistance movement compared to with only a third of the violent ones. Gandhi and King were right, but without data, you would never know it.
Though the urge to join a violent Insurgent or terrorist group may owe more to male bonding than to just-war theory, most of the combatants probably believe that if they want to bring about a better world, they have no choice but to kill people. What would happen if everyone knew that violent strategies were not just immoral but ineffectual? It's not that I think we should airdrop crates of Chenoweth and Stevens book into conflict zones. But leaders are radical groups are often highly educated (they just steal their frenzy from academic scribblers of a few years back), and even the cannon fodder often attend some college and absorb about the conventional wisdom about the need for violence. What would happen over the long run if a standard college curriculum devoted less attention to the writings of Karl Marx and Frantz Fanon and more to quantitative analysis of political violence?
-----
That's enough. You have probably not read this far anyway. Buy the book, get from your library. Whatever works. And let me know what you think.
Tuesday, February 20, 2018
Gun Control - or NOT!
Gun Control - or NOT!
Along with the rest of the nation, I have been reading quite a bit about gun control of late. There is something about young children being shot in their school that hits home with all of us. This piece is a summary of some of that reading, with links to the better pieces I have found, and a reflection, based on my very small exposure to culture in other countries. It starts with this brief summary, which is then elucidated in the larger piece. I present it this way because, you know, most of us do not read much! If the summary makes sense, check out the details below.
Summary
US Culture is very different
If you have not lived outside of the US, you may not realize that people do not think and operate the same around the world. This "world view" or "way of thinking" is often called their "culture". And that culture only changes very slowly. Good research indicates that the prevailing attitude toward guns and violence in the US goes way back to our founding nations. Some portions of our federation have roots in individualism and violence that are persist to today. If you have read Hillbilly Elegy, or 11 Nations of America, you will have read stories of past and present violent behavior that you probably found quite amazing. It is not an unusual in many parts of our country for people to use a gun as their first option to settle a dispute. It is quite common for southern "gentlemen" to become physically enraged by a mere insult. See this piece. It's just one example of the extensive research on our nation psyche.
American Violence
We are a nation born in violence, and reared in more violence. Our original settlers were either highborn religious fanatics, or the dregs of society - depending. The various parts of the country hated each other, and regularly attacked, killed and maimed each other. That is a simple fact of history. Here's a bit of a thoughtful piece on that history. It is not going to change easily. This is another article from the Smithsonian on this violent history.
https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/the-shocking-savagery-of-americas-early-history-22739301/
Violence is not seen as a problem by many of our citizens, but rather as the way to solve problems - and guns are the most likely tool to further that resolution. We wiped out the native population, imported slave labor, used vigilante justice to settle disputes in all parts of the country, used violence to solve our labor problems, and our segregation issues. We hang people we do not like, we blow up their churches and buildings. We are our own best terrorists. It would be a worthwhile undertaking to change that, but it is not going away in any hurry.
https://newrepublic.com/article/143361/america-always-angry-violent
Problems and Approaches in Other Cultures
I know that there are cultures that are probably as violent or more so than the U.S. But I would like to draw your attention to a slightly different problem faced by other cultures, that we do not seem to have. But they have recognized the problem, and have taken steps to manage it.
Italy and Money
I had the good fortune to live in Italy for a number of years. I love Italians - but there are clearly things that I would not want to replicate. In every bank in Italy, only one person in the entire bank handles any funds - the cashier. Everyone else does the numbers, and gives you a slip of paper, which you then carry to the cashier. The cashier takes your slip, exchanges the funds, and makes a record of the transaction. At the end of the day, all of those accounts had better balance or someone is in deep trouble.
If you go to the post office in Italy, the clerk only has a limited number of stamps, and a limited amount of cash. The supervisor in the rear manages all of the inventory of stamps, and doles out the cash to the different clerks. At the end of the day, those accounts must balance.
If you go into a bar in Rome to get a drink or something to eat, you present your request to the cashier at the back of the room, and he / she gives you a receipt, which you then present to the barrista to obtain your product. At the end of the day, those slips of paper must balance.
Italians are nice people, but, at least from Rome south, they are fundamentally dishonest. They will steal anything not nailed down - so everything has to be nailed down. That is simply a fact of life. They have adapted to it or there would be no retail trade, no banking.
Nicaragua and Armed Guards
I have had the good fortune to travel to Nicaragua on several occasions. I have good friends there. I love the Nicaraguans and how they see life. But they have some issues with money. It is a very poor country, and robbery and theft is not uncommon. When you approach a bank in Nicaragua the armed guards ask you what your business is. If you go to pay your cable bill in Esteli, a town of 100,000 people, you must pass the armed guards. Theft is a serious problem, and they have created a solution for it.
Tanzania and Guards
I have had the good fortune to visit Africa on several occasions, staying for many weeks. You do not see a single gas station anywhere in the country without some sort of guard. The larger ones have armed security guards, the smaller ones might have a single man with some form of weapon, most likely not a gun.
Robbery in the US
We have some armed robbery in this country, of banks and convenience stores. We have lots of security cameras to try to deter this, but it still happens. What would we do if every single store or bank was robbed at least once a week or so? There would be a public outcry, and a call for change - but I am willing to bet that we would soon see armed guards at every one of those institutions, and we would all end up picking up the tab for that. Otherwise we would not have banks or retail stores. Fortunately, we do not have that cultural problem, but we do have one with violence.
The 2nd Amendment Argument
The 2nd amendment was part of a compromise called the Bill of Rights, that was drafted to get some of the separate nations that founded this country to adopt the constitution that created a federation of nations. Some were fearful that the federal government might replicate the oppression of King George, and they thought that providing for militias at the state level would get some of the more reluctant states to buy in. Whatever meaning is given to this part of the constitution by the Supreme Court, that will not change how we see guns and violence.
Articles on Gun Control
I have found these interesting. If you work your way through these, you will understand most of the "progressive" view on this issue. I confess that I cannot help much with the "conservative" view - whatever that is.
You won't like this solution
You have to admire the title chosen by this author - talk about click-bait. His main point is that about the ONLY thing we can do is to reach out to those loners among us, and help them to connect. He sees every other practical step as fraught with problems.
https://mystudentapt.com/2015/10/06/theres-a-way-to-stop-mass-shootings-and-you-wont-like-it/
He does a nice summary of why any real change is probably not going to happen. He does tie the issue to our real world, but he does not touch on the cultural or value issues underlying this discussion. Toward the end of the piece, he cites the next article.
Sam Harris
This is a pretty in depth evaluation of the pros and cons of various efforts at gun control. He wrote in a number of years ago in respond to Sandy Hook. It has been both praised and criticized.
https://samharris.org/the-riddle-of-the-gun/
Harris owns guns, and likes the idea that he can defend himself if need be. He points to the impossibility of depending on calling 911 to defend yourself at home, as opposed to confronting an invader with a weapon. I hear a flavor of conservative fear in there. He wants to control his own destiny.
He does a nice job on the statistics - from the number of guns out there, to the small risk actually present in our schools. He definitely leans into the idea of protecting our schools with more guns. He finally opinions that actually preventing "low frequency" events like school shootings is probably impossible. It is just part of our way of life, I guess. He handles the 2nd amendment well. It is a simple distraction from the real problem. Its original intent has been totally bastardized by the gun lobby.
His final recommendation is: "Rather than new laws, I believe we need a general shift in our attitude toward public violence—wherein everyone begins to assume some responsibility for containing it." I agree there, and he is on to something, but I do not think he quite understands it.
FaceBook Post
A friend of mine, a school teacher, reposted a very nice summary of the discussion. I think you can find it here https://www.facebook.com/callista.kline/posts/10101483270002069. If the link stops working for some reason, I copied the text out and have it available here for public viewing. It is a young man writing to his mom about her view of gun control. He is a veteran, knows a fair amount, and was concerned that her somewhat naive approach would be ridiculed.
It reads very well, and is amazingly concise - witness my verbose efforts by contrast. He comes down in favor of universal background checks, and mental health screening. He mentions some other really good ideas: - registering all firearms - think automobiles'; - requiring insurance for all firearms - think automobiles again. Nicely done indeed.
BUT . . . I do not see our cultural history and political climate allowing ANY of these changes to happen. Good or bad ideas, our current state of affairs is not going to support any of these.
He mentions the idea of having armed security guards at the doors of all schools, but thinks it would potentially increase the risk that one of those folk would also become unhinged. Note that my proposal is NOT for armed security guards, but rather for highly trained, regularly tested and vetted police officers. A different breed of cat, I think.
Examples of Other Countries
Yes, I have been to other countries, and I know they handle guns very differently - they think about violence and guns very differently. In Britain, for example, the police do not carry a weapon. They feel it is too dangerous, and there is no need. And they are right - for their culture and history. Imagine a NY city cop on the beat without his weapon! I don't think so. Japan is another example, where the general populace has forsworn most violence, and guns in particular. But, in my humble opinion, the public sentiment, the basic violent culture of our nation is not going to change, no matter how many marches we undertake, or even how many politicians we replace.
A Pragmatic Step
Given that our penchant to violence and to gun violence in particular is not going away soon, and that our political system is not going to respond in any meaningful way - is there anything at all that we can do?
A Cop in Every School
In my experience, every school I visit has a single entrance during the day. And it is secured, and must be opened from the inside. Why not position a single, highly trained police officer at that door with a gun? This raises some obvious questions:
For some reason, I think the threat of gun violence in our schools can move all of us to SOME action. Let's make it a practical one that looks like it would have some impact.
Along with the rest of the nation, I have been reading quite a bit about gun control of late. There is something about young children being shot in their school that hits home with all of us. This piece is a summary of some of that reading, with links to the better pieces I have found, and a reflection, based on my very small exposure to culture in other countries. It starts with this brief summary, which is then elucidated in the larger piece. I present it this way because, you know, most of us do not read much! If the summary makes sense, check out the details below.
Summary
- The culture of the US is very different from other countries - for good or ill. We are a violent culture from our history and our values.
- Other nations have far less violence for very complicated reasons.
- Some nations have far more crime and corruption than the US, and some of those countries have adapted to their local conditions with practical solutions that work.
- The arguments for gun control are excellent - here are a few summaries.
- Gun control in the US is not something amenable to rational discussion and political action, and gun control efforts will not succeed in current culture and climate.
- We need to recognize and accept our own culture as it is, and deal with the issue in a more blunt fashion.
- For a modest investment, we could place a highly trained police officer at the entrance door to every school building in the country. There are arguments against this - but my gut says that this would be very popular with the NRA and those who will resist every other rational step. And it would at least make school shootings much more difficult.
US Culture is very different
If you have not lived outside of the US, you may not realize that people do not think and operate the same around the world. This "world view" or "way of thinking" is often called their "culture". And that culture only changes very slowly. Good research indicates that the prevailing attitude toward guns and violence in the US goes way back to our founding nations. Some portions of our federation have roots in individualism and violence that are persist to today. If you have read Hillbilly Elegy, or 11 Nations of America, you will have read stories of past and present violent behavior that you probably found quite amazing. It is not an unusual in many parts of our country for people to use a gun as their first option to settle a dispute. It is quite common for southern "gentlemen" to become physically enraged by a mere insult. See this piece. It's just one example of the extensive research on our nation psyche.
American Violence
We are a nation born in violence, and reared in more violence. Our original settlers were either highborn religious fanatics, or the dregs of society - depending. The various parts of the country hated each other, and regularly attacked, killed and maimed each other. That is a simple fact of history. Here's a bit of a thoughtful piece on that history. It is not going to change easily. This is another article from the Smithsonian on this violent history.
https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/the-shocking-savagery-of-americas-early-history-22739301/
Violence is not seen as a problem by many of our citizens, but rather as the way to solve problems - and guns are the most likely tool to further that resolution. We wiped out the native population, imported slave labor, used vigilante justice to settle disputes in all parts of the country, used violence to solve our labor problems, and our segregation issues. We hang people we do not like, we blow up their churches and buildings. We are our own best terrorists. It would be a worthwhile undertaking to change that, but it is not going away in any hurry.
https://newrepublic.com/article/143361/america-always-angry-violent
Problems and Approaches in Other Cultures
I know that there are cultures that are probably as violent or more so than the U.S. But I would like to draw your attention to a slightly different problem faced by other cultures, that we do not seem to have. But they have recognized the problem, and have taken steps to manage it.
Italy and Money
I had the good fortune to live in Italy for a number of years. I love Italians - but there are clearly things that I would not want to replicate. In every bank in Italy, only one person in the entire bank handles any funds - the cashier. Everyone else does the numbers, and gives you a slip of paper, which you then carry to the cashier. The cashier takes your slip, exchanges the funds, and makes a record of the transaction. At the end of the day, all of those accounts had better balance or someone is in deep trouble.
If you go to the post office in Italy, the clerk only has a limited number of stamps, and a limited amount of cash. The supervisor in the rear manages all of the inventory of stamps, and doles out the cash to the different clerks. At the end of the day, those accounts must balance.
If you go into a bar in Rome to get a drink or something to eat, you present your request to the cashier at the back of the room, and he / she gives you a receipt, which you then present to the barrista to obtain your product. At the end of the day, those slips of paper must balance.
Italians are nice people, but, at least from Rome south, they are fundamentally dishonest. They will steal anything not nailed down - so everything has to be nailed down. That is simply a fact of life. They have adapted to it or there would be no retail trade, no banking.
Nicaragua and Armed Guards
I have had the good fortune to travel to Nicaragua on several occasions. I have good friends there. I love the Nicaraguans and how they see life. But they have some issues with money. It is a very poor country, and robbery and theft is not uncommon. When you approach a bank in Nicaragua the armed guards ask you what your business is. If you go to pay your cable bill in Esteli, a town of 100,000 people, you must pass the armed guards. Theft is a serious problem, and they have created a solution for it.
Tanzania and Guards
I have had the good fortune to visit Africa on several occasions, staying for many weeks. You do not see a single gas station anywhere in the country without some sort of guard. The larger ones have armed security guards, the smaller ones might have a single man with some form of weapon, most likely not a gun.
Robbery in the US
We have some armed robbery in this country, of banks and convenience stores. We have lots of security cameras to try to deter this, but it still happens. What would we do if every single store or bank was robbed at least once a week or so? There would be a public outcry, and a call for change - but I am willing to bet that we would soon see armed guards at every one of those institutions, and we would all end up picking up the tab for that. Otherwise we would not have banks or retail stores. Fortunately, we do not have that cultural problem, but we do have one with violence.
The 2nd Amendment Argument
The 2nd amendment was part of a compromise called the Bill of Rights, that was drafted to get some of the separate nations that founded this country to adopt the constitution that created a federation of nations. Some were fearful that the federal government might replicate the oppression of King George, and they thought that providing for militias at the state level would get some of the more reluctant states to buy in. Whatever meaning is given to this part of the constitution by the Supreme Court, that will not change how we see guns and violence.
Articles on Gun Control
I have found these interesting. If you work your way through these, you will understand most of the "progressive" view on this issue. I confess that I cannot help much with the "conservative" view - whatever that is.
You won't like this solution
You have to admire the title chosen by this author - talk about click-bait. His main point is that about the ONLY thing we can do is to reach out to those loners among us, and help them to connect. He sees every other practical step as fraught with problems.
https://mystudentapt.com/2015/10/06/theres-a-way-to-stop-mass-shootings-and-you-wont-like-it/
He does a nice summary of why any real change is probably not going to happen. He does tie the issue to our real world, but he does not touch on the cultural or value issues underlying this discussion. Toward the end of the piece, he cites the next article.
Sam Harris
This is a pretty in depth evaluation of the pros and cons of various efforts at gun control. He wrote in a number of years ago in respond to Sandy Hook. It has been both praised and criticized.
https://samharris.org/the-riddle-of-the-gun/
Harris owns guns, and likes the idea that he can defend himself if need be. He points to the impossibility of depending on calling 911 to defend yourself at home, as opposed to confronting an invader with a weapon. I hear a flavor of conservative fear in there. He wants to control his own destiny.
He does a nice job on the statistics - from the number of guns out there, to the small risk actually present in our schools. He definitely leans into the idea of protecting our schools with more guns. He finally opinions that actually preventing "low frequency" events like school shootings is probably impossible. It is just part of our way of life, I guess. He handles the 2nd amendment well. It is a simple distraction from the real problem. Its original intent has been totally bastardized by the gun lobby.
His final recommendation is: "Rather than new laws, I believe we need a general shift in our attitude toward public violence—wherein everyone begins to assume some responsibility for containing it." I agree there, and he is on to something, but I do not think he quite understands it.
FaceBook Post
A friend of mine, a school teacher, reposted a very nice summary of the discussion. I think you can find it here https://www.facebook.com/callista.kline/posts/10101483270002069. If the link stops working for some reason, I copied the text out and have it available here for public viewing. It is a young man writing to his mom about her view of gun control. He is a veteran, knows a fair amount, and was concerned that her somewhat naive approach would be ridiculed.
It reads very well, and is amazingly concise - witness my verbose efforts by contrast. He comes down in favor of universal background checks, and mental health screening. He mentions some other really good ideas: - registering all firearms - think automobiles'; - requiring insurance for all firearms - think automobiles again. Nicely done indeed.
BUT . . . I do not see our cultural history and political climate allowing ANY of these changes to happen. Good or bad ideas, our current state of affairs is not going to support any of these.
He mentions the idea of having armed security guards at the doors of all schools, but thinks it would potentially increase the risk that one of those folk would also become unhinged. Note that my proposal is NOT for armed security guards, but rather for highly trained, regularly tested and vetted police officers. A different breed of cat, I think.
Examples of Other Countries
Yes, I have been to other countries, and I know they handle guns very differently - they think about violence and guns very differently. In Britain, for example, the police do not carry a weapon. They feel it is too dangerous, and there is no need. And they are right - for their culture and history. Imagine a NY city cop on the beat without his weapon! I don't think so. Japan is another example, where the general populace has forsworn most violence, and guns in particular. But, in my humble opinion, the public sentiment, the basic violent culture of our nation is not going to change, no matter how many marches we undertake, or even how many politicians we replace.
A Pragmatic Step
Given that our penchant to violence and to gun violence in particular is not going away soon, and that our political system is not going to respond in any meaningful way - is there anything at all that we can do?
A Cop in Every School
In my experience, every school I visit has a single entrance during the day. And it is secured, and must be opened from the inside. Why not position a single, highly trained police officer at that door with a gun? This raises some obvious questions:
- Would it work? Only research can tell us that, but my gut says it would work, and my gut says that I would feel a lot better about having done something to deter school shootings.
- Could it make the problem worse? We now have an armed person in every school. But this armed person is a highly trained professional, who knows how to deal with threats, violent and otherwise. This professional is chosen and trained specifically for this task of protecting our priceless children. And they will be periodically vetted and reviewed for their skills and mental stability.
- Can this be enacted? I am of the considered opinion that we could get this to pass at local state level, and at the national level. The NRA is NOT going to oppose it. They have been lobbying in support of it. What's not to like? It fits perfectly with our violent culture. It asks our most trusted civil servants, our police, to take on one more burden for our violence prone society. I doubt that they will decline. And if some states opt to not take part, so be it - they will bear the burden of explaining why in the event of any future attacks.
- What would it cost? According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the average police officer salary in our country is now about $61,000. If we add 20% to that for fringe benefits, we get about $73,000. According to the National Center of Education Statistics, we have about 98,000 public schools, and 34,000 private schools. We clearly do not want to leave out the private schools, but we could make can an argument that they should bear their own cost. By simple arithmetic, we get to a total annual cost of $9.7 B. Our total investment in the education of our children comes to about $1 Trillion annually. This cost would represent a 1% increase in that budget. Now about 167 M of us are gainfully employed and pay SS tax, according to Pew Research. If we did the least progressive thing possible, and make those people bear the total cost of this, it would average out to $58 per person per year. A good investment to my mind. That said, the federal government just voted to increase our deficit by $1 Trillion, and added $77B per year to our defense spending. Where would you spend the money?
For some reason, I think the threat of gun violence in our schools can move all of us to SOME action. Let's make it a practical one that looks like it would have some impact.
Wednesday, February 7, 2018
Emotions and Empathy and Changing Views, etc.
This is not well formed yet, but it is interesting. I am going to work on it a bit and come back to it. All ideas on this very welcome. This is "under construction" - another favorite from Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. That and "42".
We Are Not Rational
If you look at the current political climate, this is pretty obvious. People are not making rational decisions. They are voting against their own best interests. And it is not just "fake news" and Russian Facebook bots. Something else is at work. We generally do not make rational decisions. You can find a nice summary of that research here, and you can look at these books which I have reviewed previously: Thinking Fast and Slow, Righteous Minds,
Emotions Dominate
Research indicates that we are about 97% driven by our values, our emotions, our feelings. We also seem to have a genetic propensity to be either conservative or progressive. It can be moved around a bit, but it comes with the genetics. In either case, ideas are secondary at best. They are useful, but they do not drive action very much.
Group Membership Dominates
As Haidt points out, we are totally tribal. Our membership in our group gives us great comfort and support, and we find it very difficult to differ from the standard cultural norm. Some of our cultural norms are shared with the larger nation or group, but very many are much closer to home - family and friends.
BackFire is not what we thought
This blog entry covers this misconception pretty well.
https://carlscheider.blogspot.com/2018/02/it-is-not-about-facts-its-all-shared.html
The bottom line is that facts are resisted if they are counter to your beliefs or cultural values - but they are not denied. People will search for a critique of the fact, they will resist, but then they may accept it. It does not make their commitment any stronger - that is the error. But generally, they will either ignore it, or find another supporting fact for their value or belief.
One good example is the vaccination research issue. People who are resistive to having their children vaccinated because of the fear of autism, can be persuaded rationally that there is no real risk. When presented with clear facts, the actual studies, they will change their mind. BUT . . . they do NOT change their actions. Even though their rational brain now recognizes that the facts do not seem to support their belief, they continue to follow the moral guidance of their belief!
Another project was conducted by the BBC called 911 Conspiracy Road Trip. The BBC took a group of 911 conspiracy adherents on a trip to introduce them to all kinds of participants in the disaster. You can see the whole show here: https://youtu.be/Tga4hXy8qws
After extensive information from experts at every level of the disaster, only one of the participants changed his mind. He happened to have a solid support infrastructure that did not reject him when he changed his view - a girl friend and small child. He was, however, vilified by the cult, even to the extent that peole sent child pornography pictures to his mother with his child's face on them.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/10079244/The-911-conspiracy-theorist-who-changed-his-mind.html
We are driven by our social value milieu, our gut, our beliefs, our group - not by ideas. We look for ideas and facts to support our values and beliefs, not the other way around. To really change a belief or value, a lot more than information is needed.
Change Is Possible
The Podcast above mentions two successful change of view experiments that affected people's moral values, AND their actions. In one of them, a group of adherents to the
The second one research. This research was studied at length, but one of the studies used totally fictitious data, so it tended to discredit the original work. Subsequent studies have been more rigorous in their facts, and they have confirmed the results.
This study had to do with the constitutional change in California that legalized gay marriage.
So, change is possible on a one to one conversation, with an open and receptive adult, who is engaged by a mature, unthreatening, capable adult. Whew - how does one replicate that?
Social Empathy Works
This little tale precipitated all of this, so you might want to listen / watch it a bit.
WWII England Social Empathy
England is at war - resources are scarce - and yet they quickly pass a social welfare benefit for their children, because so many people were so intimately exposed to the dire straits of intercity children that they HAD to respond. I love the story, but . . .
Now What?
How in the world does one replicate that?
We Are Not Rational
If you look at the current political climate, this is pretty obvious. People are not making rational decisions. They are voting against their own best interests. And it is not just "fake news" and Russian Facebook bots. Something else is at work. We generally do not make rational decisions. You can find a nice summary of that research here, and you can look at these books which I have reviewed previously: Thinking Fast and Slow, Righteous Minds,
Emotions Dominate
Research indicates that we are about 97% driven by our values, our emotions, our feelings. We also seem to have a genetic propensity to be either conservative or progressive. It can be moved around a bit, but it comes with the genetics. In either case, ideas are secondary at best. They are useful, but they do not drive action very much.
Group Membership Dominates
As Haidt points out, we are totally tribal. Our membership in our group gives us great comfort and support, and we find it very difficult to differ from the standard cultural norm. Some of our cultural norms are shared with the larger nation or group, but very many are much closer to home - family and friends.
BackFire is not what we thought
This blog entry covers this misconception pretty well.
https://carlscheider.blogspot.com/2018/02/it-is-not-about-facts-its-all-shared.html
The bottom line is that facts are resisted if they are counter to your beliefs or cultural values - but they are not denied. People will search for a critique of the fact, they will resist, but then they may accept it. It does not make their commitment any stronger - that is the error. But generally, they will either ignore it, or find another supporting fact for their value or belief.
One good example is the vaccination research issue. People who are resistive to having their children vaccinated because of the fear of autism, can be persuaded rationally that there is no real risk. When presented with clear facts, the actual studies, they will change their mind. BUT . . . they do NOT change their actions. Even though their rational brain now recognizes that the facts do not seem to support their belief, they continue to follow the moral guidance of their belief!
Another project was conducted by the BBC called 911 Conspiracy Road Trip. The BBC took a group of 911 conspiracy adherents on a trip to introduce them to all kinds of participants in the disaster. You can see the whole show here: https://youtu.be/Tga4hXy8qws
After extensive information from experts at every level of the disaster, only one of the participants changed his mind. He happened to have a solid support infrastructure that did not reject him when he changed his view - a girl friend and small child. He was, however, vilified by the cult, even to the extent that peole sent child pornography pictures to his mother with his child's face on them.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/10079244/The-911-conspiracy-theorist-who-changed-his-mind.html
We are driven by our social value milieu, our gut, our beliefs, our group - not by ideas. We look for ideas and facts to support our values and beliefs, not the other way around. To really change a belief or value, a lot more than information is needed.
Change Is Possible
The Podcast above mentions two successful change of view experiments that affected people's moral values, AND their actions. In one of them, a group of adherents to the
The second one research. This research was studied at length, but one of the studies used totally fictitious data, so it tended to discredit the original work. Subsequent studies have been more rigorous in their facts, and they have confirmed the results.
This study had to do with the constitutional change in California that legalized gay marriage.
So, change is possible on a one to one conversation, with an open and receptive adult, who is engaged by a mature, unthreatening, capable adult. Whew - how does one replicate that?
Social Empathy Works
This little tale precipitated all of this, so you might want to listen / watch it a bit.
WWII England Social Empathy
England is at war - resources are scarce - and yet they quickly pass a social welfare benefit for their children, because so many people were so intimately exposed to the dire straits of intercity children that they HAD to respond. I love the story, but . . .
Now What?
How in the world does one replicate that?
Monday, February 5, 2018
It is NOT about the FACTS - It's all Shared Values
If you have been following along here - and I JUST know you have, this podcast documents an important insight that helps explain a bit our current situation in politics.
https://youarenotsosmart.com/2018/01/29/yanss-120-the-backfire-effect-part-four/
The Good News is that people will accept FACTS that are contrary to what they believe if they are presented clearly.
The Bad News is that our attitudes, values and such are NOT based on facts at all - but rather on the shared values we hold with others. We will find facts to support our values. If you knock one down, we will find others, or just ignore the facts altogether. If we want to move forward together, we need to work on our shared values - and how the heck do we do that?
This also means that things like meditation or mindfulness are not going to move things much. It helps to become fully aware of our shared values, but that will not change them one iota. To do that, we need to interact with others beyond our shared value circle - a rare event indeed.
This podcast had a number of episodes last year dealing with 'The Backfire Effect'. This is a highly cited paper which seemed to say that when you present facts to people, they tend to ignore things that are contrary to their values. The paper also implied somewhat that this would in fact increase their commitment to those facts because of their beliefs. Most of that understanding of the paper was not quite correct - and other researchers have found little confirmation of the Backfire Effect. So they set out to redo the studies with the original authors.
What we have learned is that FACTS are not important when we are dealing with the values or attitudes which people hold. Bluntly stated, no mountain of lies or misstatements by a person or group which we support will undermine our support for that group or value. Donald Trump or Hillary Clinton are not going to gain or lose supporters based on FACTS or information. It is the shared values that people are committed to which determine whom they support.
Giving people more information about vaccines does tend to correct their misunderstanding of the science - it does NOT tend to make them more likely to vaccinate their children. Giving people FBI statistics that gun violence has rapidly declined in recent years does not change their views about gun control. Sean Hannity did not change his view of our fearless leader when he got independent confirmation that the President did try to fire Robert Mueller last year. This fact had NO effect on his support.
We do not go from FACTS, to beliefs, to attitudes, to values, to shared values, to regional cultural norms which then influence our actions. Rather, the regional cultural norms are the key – they drive our values, which we then protect and justify with facts!
So, my question, what are the normative values that bring people to support things like protective nationalism versus inclusive humanity, and warlike bluster versus diplomacy? What shared values support cutting the taxes of the very wealthy and increasing the national debt to be paid by all of us by a trillion dollars. Is this purely the "strong leader" part of our social norms that comes from our conservative side - or it more complex?
And if we can identify those normative values, how on earth does one go about changing them - if one can at all? We are driven by values that are not rational! So? Resort to emotional persuasion. What?
I know we are all in this together - just not sure how I can help here. I also would like to put this on Facebook with a lot less words!
I would really like to understand this better. Can you hellp?
https://youarenotsosmart.com/2018/01/29/yanss-120-the-backfire-effect-part-four/
The Good News is that people will accept FACTS that are contrary to what they believe if they are presented clearly.
The Bad News is that our attitudes, values and such are NOT based on facts at all - but rather on the shared values we hold with others. We will find facts to support our values. If you knock one down, we will find others, or just ignore the facts altogether. If we want to move forward together, we need to work on our shared values - and how the heck do we do that?
This also means that things like meditation or mindfulness are not going to move things much. It helps to become fully aware of our shared values, but that will not change them one iota. To do that, we need to interact with others beyond our shared value circle - a rare event indeed.
This podcast had a number of episodes last year dealing with 'The Backfire Effect'. This is a highly cited paper which seemed to say that when you present facts to people, they tend to ignore things that are contrary to their values. The paper also implied somewhat that this would in fact increase their commitment to those facts because of their beliefs. Most of that understanding of the paper was not quite correct - and other researchers have found little confirmation of the Backfire Effect. So they set out to redo the studies with the original authors.
What we have learned is that FACTS are not important when we are dealing with the values or attitudes which people hold. Bluntly stated, no mountain of lies or misstatements by a person or group which we support will undermine our support for that group or value. Donald Trump or Hillary Clinton are not going to gain or lose supporters based on FACTS or information. It is the shared values that people are committed to which determine whom they support.
Giving people more information about vaccines does tend to correct their misunderstanding of the science - it does NOT tend to make them more likely to vaccinate their children. Giving people FBI statistics that gun violence has rapidly declined in recent years does not change their views about gun control. Sean Hannity did not change his view of our fearless leader when he got independent confirmation that the President did try to fire Robert Mueller last year. This fact had NO effect on his support.
We do not go from FACTS, to beliefs, to attitudes, to values, to shared values, to regional cultural norms which then influence our actions. Rather, the regional cultural norms are the key – they drive our values, which we then protect and justify with facts!
So, my question, what are the normative values that bring people to support things like protective nationalism versus inclusive humanity, and warlike bluster versus diplomacy? What shared values support cutting the taxes of the very wealthy and increasing the national debt to be paid by all of us by a trillion dollars. Is this purely the "strong leader" part of our social norms that comes from our conservative side - or it more complex?
And if we can identify those normative values, how on earth does one go about changing them - if one can at all? We are driven by values that are not rational! So? Resort to emotional persuasion. What?
I would really like to understand this better. Can you hellp?
Monday, January 22, 2018
Story Telling - Who Knew?
I love stories - I'll bet you do too. The evidence is pretty clear. We sat around fires for hundreds of thousands of years and told each other stories. We did it in rhythm and rhyme, with poetry and music and dance. It is how we formed ourselves into families and tribes of shared values. It is how we passed on wisdom and knowledge. Now neuroscientists are trying to figure out just how this storytelling thing works.
When we interact with other people, we create a storyline in our head about them. We are ourselves this one continuous story line. We plan ahead by creating a story into the future. We empathize with others by participating in their story. One thing is for sure, those Artificial Intelligence things we are creating do not tell stories - at least not yet. And other animals do not seem to have much of this story telling ability. Dolphins may, but other animals do not seem to be that complex.
This entry is all about stories or narratives. Let me tell you a couple.
You may not realize this, but that sacred book of sacred books, the Bible, is a collection of oral stories that people loved and shared for hundreds or thousands of years before they were written down. They were used in rituals and celebrations to create our people, our tribe. Why do you think the psalms were sung? Rhythm and rhyme made stories much easier to remember. The New Testament is the same, but those stories were written down in just a few decades, because we knew how to write. But, remember, MOST people could not read, and had never even seen a book or parchment. That is why the oral storytelling was so important. It was why they gathered together - to share the stories.
Creation
The creation story is about origins and values. You know that Genesis tells the story of creation. This is the tale that the Church used for millennia to "prove" that the world was 7,000 years old. The Jewish people created these tales to give themselves a shared understanding of the meaning of life. If the deity was all powerful and wonderful, why are there are so many BAD things about human life and death. Why is there evil in the world? What sort of deity would condemn its beloved children to death? The story of Adam and Eve helped explain that. The deity set things up perfectly - the garden of Eden provided everything humans needed. But we sinned - we offended the almighty, and this vale of tears is the result.
Most people do not know this, but there are TWO creation stories in Genesis. The first one is the majestic tale of the 7 days of creation. The 7 days, of course, gave rise to our week, and to the Jewish veneration of the 7th day - the Sabbath - as a day of rest. The second creation story follows immediately in the second chapter of Genesis. There are no seven days here - God created Adam, MAN, first. Then he gave the earth rain, and created Eden, and caused plants to grow there. Then God created a partner for the man. The rest of this story is about the fall from Eden - the "original sin" of later Christian or Pauline theology.
A Missionary Story
In the 1960s, an old friend of mine was a newly commissioned missionary. He was sent to Africa to the Maasai people. He was excited to have this opportunity to bring the good news to this people. The Maasai had not really had the gospel preached to them to this point. They were the fertile field waiting for the seed. Every Saturday, my friend went out to a small town with an interpreter, and he began to tell the stories of salvation. He told the story of creation, about the fall of Adam and Eve, and the many other tales in the Old Testament. We have Noah, and the Exodus, and slavery in Egypt, and Moses, and the promised land of Israel, and many other tales. As the Bible stories have it, the Jewish people are the chosen people of God. When he came to the New Testament, he told about the birth of the Savior, about his life and his stories. He spoke about the promise of forgiveness, and about resurrection.
Each week the crowd of listeners would grow larger. He spoke of his church and religion, and he invited people to join him - but no one would come forward. He began to feel despondent. He mentioned to his translator and some of the elders that he was going to stop coming. They told him, "NO, you have to keep coming. We love your stories?" He was the Saturday night entertainment in this small town on the Serengeti. He said, "But no one ever wants to join my church." They replied, "Oh, those are YOUR stories". We have our own stories." He was dumbfounded. All this time, and he had not heard of their stories. So they proceeded to explain to him how the deity, a woman, had given birth to all living things. They explained how the deity gave all of the cattle on earth to the Maasai. They explained how the jealous wife had broken the promise of resurrection, and why death was in the world. They told the story of how houses moved with the Maasai at one time and the evil deed that caused that to stop. So, they had their own creation story, their own fall from grace. Their stories explained how the Maasai were God's chosen people.
As it turns out, every people has an origin story, and a story of how evil came to be. When there are multiple deities, the problem is a bit easier - the deities generally do not get along well. We have a shred of that in the Judeo Christian heritage with angels and devils, but they are all subject to the supreme being. These stories help a people become a tribe, an entity of mutual commitment and belonging because they have a shared mythology - a shared history of values and events that give their life meaning.
Family Stories
My lovely wife's dad, Wayne, loved to tell stories. And our kids always loved hearing them. When he died, we all gathered in our living room and repeated his stories to each other. We still remember this fine, gentle man, and his stories about growing up in a log cabin, about the first automobile, about using the farm horses to get the car out of the ditch, about fishing with dynamite - and many, many more. His stories gave us a feeling for what it was like to grow up in northern Minnesota in the 1920s.
Disney
We have a preeminent story teller in our world - Disney! This was a surprise to me, but Disney has a chief scientist! That person's mandate is to keep an eye on where things are going, and make sure that Disney has a hand in it. I attended a talk he gave in about 1991. It's hard to believe that the WWW is less than 30 years old. The internet was around for a while - but it consisted of some arcane languages, and you communicated with people via commands of various types. CompuServe was one of the first commercial providers that tried to make it easier to use. And the University of MN invented something called a Gopher - if you used it, it would create a usable structure or index of the information that each internet address had available. It was a great boon to research.
And then came Sir Tim Berners-Lee, and the WWW!
https://webfoundation.org/about/vision/history-of-the-web/
He invented this whole idea of linking, and naming, and graphics, and the whole ball of wax called the World Wide Web. HTML was a simple way to build formatted information that was really, really easy to use. URL gave us a standard way to identify websites. And HTTP a standard protocol for the retrieval of linked information across the internet.
At this talk the chief scientist told us that Disney's whole task and focus is on telling stories. And they know that people love stories - we have been listening to them for thousands of years. So he asked the audience - what do you think of this World Wide Web business? Is this CB radio? Here today, gone tomorrow? Or is it FIRE! Will it change everything? Disney thought then that it was FIRE! He predicted that within 15 years, everyone on the planet would have a hand-held gadget, with live video, and simultaneous translation, for the price of a paperback book. Well, he was a bit optimistic about the price, but you can, today, buy a FIRE from Amazon that will do all of that, for less than $50.
I'll add more stories later. I've been sitting on this draft for a few months. I'll come up with some more stories later! Hang in there - remember, I'm pulling for you.
When we interact with other people, we create a storyline in our head about them. We are ourselves this one continuous story line. We plan ahead by creating a story into the future. We empathize with others by participating in their story. One thing is for sure, those Artificial Intelligence things we are creating do not tell stories - at least not yet. And other animals do not seem to have much of this story telling ability. Dolphins may, but other animals do not seem to be that complex.
This entry is all about stories or narratives. Let me tell you a couple.
Creation
The creation story is about origins and values. You know that Genesis tells the story of creation. This is the tale that the Church used for millennia to "prove" that the world was 7,000 years old. The Jewish people created these tales to give themselves a shared understanding of the meaning of life. If the deity was all powerful and wonderful, why are there are so many BAD things about human life and death. Why is there evil in the world? What sort of deity would condemn its beloved children to death? The story of Adam and Eve helped explain that. The deity set things up perfectly - the garden of Eden provided everything humans needed. But we sinned - we offended the almighty, and this vale of tears is the result.
Most people do not know this, but there are TWO creation stories in Genesis. The first one is the majestic tale of the 7 days of creation. The 7 days, of course, gave rise to our week, and to the Jewish veneration of the 7th day - the Sabbath - as a day of rest. The second creation story follows immediately in the second chapter of Genesis. There are no seven days here - God created Adam, MAN, first. Then he gave the earth rain, and created Eden, and caused plants to grow there. Then God created a partner for the man. The rest of this story is about the fall from Eden - the "original sin" of later Christian or Pauline theology.
A Missionary Story
In the 1960s, an old friend of mine was a newly commissioned missionary. He was sent to Africa to the Maasai people. He was excited to have this opportunity to bring the good news to this people. The Maasai had not really had the gospel preached to them to this point. They were the fertile field waiting for the seed. Every Saturday, my friend went out to a small town with an interpreter, and he began to tell the stories of salvation. He told the story of creation, about the fall of Adam and Eve, and the many other tales in the Old Testament. We have Noah, and the Exodus, and slavery in Egypt, and Moses, and the promised land of Israel, and many other tales. As the Bible stories have it, the Jewish people are the chosen people of God. When he came to the New Testament, he told about the birth of the Savior, about his life and his stories. He spoke about the promise of forgiveness, and about resurrection.
Each week the crowd of listeners would grow larger. He spoke of his church and religion, and he invited people to join him - but no one would come forward. He began to feel despondent. He mentioned to his translator and some of the elders that he was going to stop coming. They told him, "NO, you have to keep coming. We love your stories?" He was the Saturday night entertainment in this small town on the Serengeti. He said, "But no one ever wants to join my church." They replied, "Oh, those are YOUR stories". We have our own stories." He was dumbfounded. All this time, and he had not heard of their stories. So they proceeded to explain to him how the deity, a woman, had given birth to all living things. They explained how the deity gave all of the cattle on earth to the Maasai. They explained how the jealous wife had broken the promise of resurrection, and why death was in the world. They told the story of how houses moved with the Maasai at one time and the evil deed that caused that to stop. So, they had their own creation story, their own fall from grace. Their stories explained how the Maasai were God's chosen people.
As it turns out, every people has an origin story, and a story of how evil came to be. When there are multiple deities, the problem is a bit easier - the deities generally do not get along well. We have a shred of that in the Judeo Christian heritage with angels and devils, but they are all subject to the supreme being. These stories help a people become a tribe, an entity of mutual commitment and belonging because they have a shared mythology - a shared history of values and events that give their life meaning.
Family Stories
My lovely wife's dad, Wayne, loved to tell stories. And our kids always loved hearing them. When he died, we all gathered in our living room and repeated his stories to each other. We still remember this fine, gentle man, and his stories about growing up in a log cabin, about the first automobile, about using the farm horses to get the car out of the ditch, about fishing with dynamite - and many, many more. His stories gave us a feeling for what it was like to grow up in northern Minnesota in the 1920s.
Disney
We have a preeminent story teller in our world - Disney! This was a surprise to me, but Disney has a chief scientist! That person's mandate is to keep an eye on where things are going, and make sure that Disney has a hand in it. I attended a talk he gave in about 1991. It's hard to believe that the WWW is less than 30 years old. The internet was around for a while - but it consisted of some arcane languages, and you communicated with people via commands of various types. CompuServe was one of the first commercial providers that tried to make it easier to use. And the University of MN invented something called a Gopher - if you used it, it would create a usable structure or index of the information that each internet address had available. It was a great boon to research.
And then came Sir Tim Berners-Lee, and the WWW!
https://webfoundation.org/about/vision/history-of-the-web/
He invented this whole idea of linking, and naming, and graphics, and the whole ball of wax called the World Wide Web. HTML was a simple way to build formatted information that was really, really easy to use. URL gave us a standard way to identify websites. And HTTP a standard protocol for the retrieval of linked information across the internet.
At this talk the chief scientist told us that Disney's whole task and focus is on telling stories. And they know that people love stories - we have been listening to them for thousands of years. So he asked the audience - what do you think of this World Wide Web business? Is this CB radio? Here today, gone tomorrow? Or is it FIRE! Will it change everything? Disney thought then that it was FIRE! He predicted that within 15 years, everyone on the planet would have a hand-held gadget, with live video, and simultaneous translation, for the price of a paperback book. Well, he was a bit optimistic about the price, but you can, today, buy a FIRE from Amazon that will do all of that, for less than $50.
I'll add more stories later. I've been sitting on this draft for a few months. I'll come up with some more stories later! Hang in there - remember, I'm pulling for you.
Cognitive Science and Mindfulness
That last little piece in the this blog was pretty good, but I just found a wonderful 'little' essay that does it even better. See:
https://aeon.co/essays/are-you-sleepwalking-now-what-we-know-about-mind-wandering?utm_source=Aeon+Newsletter&utm_campaign=98d44d51c9-EMAIL_CAMPAIGN_2018_01_21&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_411a82e59d-98d44d51c9-68782273
I just posted this to Facebook, hoping that a few more than 8 people will read it. And thank you very much for reading here as well.
I have been reading a lot about neuroscience lately - since I read Thinking, Fast and Slow by Kahneman. This essay is a wonderful compilation of the latest neuroscience research, with a philosophical cast to it. It gives me hope. Realizing we ourselves and mostly everyone else are not really rational most of the time is one thing - finding a way to actually do something about that is a tremendous insight. Guess what - mindfulness. I had the good fortune to spend a decade or so in an institution that forced me to do this for 30 minutes each day - I continue it at a somewhat shorter pace - but it is enormously powerful. This essay lays out the biological research, and a philosophical framework for understanding that and doing something with it.
If you find that interesting and exciting, read it. If you can't get your wandering brain to pay attention to the end of this note - you REALLY need to read it!
I just wonder how long it will take for this to become a fundamental part of our education and literature understanding of human kind. With the type of fearless leaders we have now, we may be at this a long time.
Hang in there - I'm pulling for you, and we really are all in this together.
https://aeon.co/essays/are-you-sleepwalking-now-what-we-know-about-mind-wandering?utm_source=Aeon+Newsletter&utm_campaign=98d44d51c9-EMAIL_CAMPAIGN_2018_01_21&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_411a82e59d-98d44d51c9-68782273
I just posted this to Facebook, hoping that a few more than 8 people will read it. And thank you very much for reading here as well.
I have been reading a lot about neuroscience lately - since I read Thinking, Fast and Slow by Kahneman. This essay is a wonderful compilation of the latest neuroscience research, with a philosophical cast to it. It gives me hope. Realizing we ourselves and mostly everyone else are not really rational most of the time is one thing - finding a way to actually do something about that is a tremendous insight. Guess what - mindfulness. I had the good fortune to spend a decade or so in an institution that forced me to do this for 30 minutes each day - I continue it at a somewhat shorter pace - but it is enormously powerful. This essay lays out the biological research, and a philosophical framework for understanding that and doing something with it.
If you find that interesting and exciting, read it. If you can't get your wandering brain to pay attention to the end of this note - you REALLY need to read it!
I just wonder how long it will take for this to become a fundamental part of our education and literature understanding of human kind. With the type of fearless leaders we have now, we may be at this a long time.
Hang in there - I'm pulling for you, and we really are all in this together.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)